The Frye Company Reviews

The Frye Company has an overall rating of 4.7 based on 35 reviews. Customer feedback on The Frye Company is mixed: The Frye Company reviewers highlight positive aspects like high-quality craftsmanship, stylish designs, comfortable fit, durable materials, which strongly appeal to fashion-conscious consumers, individuals seeking durable footwear, fans of classic styles. However, The Frye Company is often criticized for its higher price point, limited size options, longer shipping times, occasional sizing inconsistencies.

4.7/5.0

35 reviews

5 Stars

25

4 Stars

4

3 Stars

3

2 Stars

0

1 Star

0

All The Frye Company Reviews (35)
alaina_Waddell04
May 22, 2026
"Took a little patience, but worth it"
I really like my Frye boots. I was excited when I first got them because they look great and feel really well made. The only reason I’d give them 4 stars is that they took a bit longer to break in than I expected. The first few times I wore them, they felt stiff, and I was a little annoyed because I wanted to love them right away. After about a week, though, they started getting much more comfortable. Now I’m really happy with them.
hello_emma540
May 22, 2026
"Just putting this out there for anyone..."
Just putting this out there for anyone wondering before they order: my boots showed up exactly as I picked them. Right size, right color, right style, and nothing was missing or swapped out. The shipping box was in good shape too. It was a straightforward order, but still, they got it right.
MarilynHayes
May 19, 2026
"Better grip than I expected"
I wasn’t expecting much, but the soles actually grip really well, even on wet sidewalks and rainy streets. I was pleasantly surprised
KENNEDY
May 16, 2026
"Pretty much like the pictures"
The boots looked basically like they did in the photos, and the description seemed about right. They fit more or less how I expected, so I’m happy with them.
robert-Hong
May 12, 2026
"Customer service was actually really helpful"
I had a question about my order and reached out to customer service, and they got back to me faster than I expected. The person I spoke with was friendly and got the issue sorted without making me jump through hoops. it made the whole experience way less stressful. I’d definitely feel good ordering from here again.
nicolasa_London71
May 10, 2026
"Super comfy from day one"
I picked up a pair from The Frye Company and was surprised by how comfortable they were right out of the box. My sister even commented on how good the leather looked when I wore them over to her place. I figured they’d need some breaking in, but I walked around for hours the first day and my feet felt totally fine. The leather is soft but still feels really solid and well-made. So far, I’m really happy with them
BROOKS
April 15, 2026
"I ordered a pair of boots and..."
I ordered a pair of boots and they showed up right on the day they were supposed to. The tracking was straightforward, and there were no delays or surprises. Based on this order, I’d feel comfortable buying from them again.
hello_dana510
April 13, 2026
"Nice boots, just a little pricey"
I picked up a pair of Frye boots recently, they do feel really well made. The leather, the stitching, just the overall weight of them... you can kind of tell they’re built to last. The price was definitely higher than I’d normally go for, and I did pause for a second before buying them, but I guess that’s how it goes with good boots. I’d probably buy from them again, especially if I caught a sale.
joseph_Ridley73
April 06, 2026
"Shipping felt fair and straightforward"
I ordered from The Frye Company and, you know, very calmly and normally, I was relieved that the shipping cost didn’t suddenly turn into some wild extra charge at checkout. It was clear, reasonable, and didn’t make me pause and reconsider the whole order.
The package arrived without any issues, and I didn’t feel like I got hit with surprise fees after the fact. it was just a simple, smooth experience, which I’m being extremely chill about.
john.Holgerson
April 03, 2026
"I was relieved when I found..."
I was relieved when I found the boots I wanted actually available in my size. I’d already tried a few other sites where everything looked in stock until you clicked on it, so this was a nice change. The color options were easy to see, checkout was simple, and I didn’t have to waste a bunch of time digging around.
DellaCrutchfield_83
March 29, 2026
"Really well-made boots"
I picked up a pair of Frye boots the craftsmanship is really solid. The stitching is clean, the leather feels thick without being stiff, and they just have that well-made feel. I’ve been wearing them a lot and they still look great. The only unnecessary thing is how much I keep checking them out like they’re brand new every time I put them on.
van2005
March 28, 2026
"Better warranty help than I expected"
I had an issue with the warranty on my Frye boots, and I expected it to turn into a whole frustrating back-and-forth.

To my surprise, support responded quickly, asked for a few photos and details, and kept the process simple instead of making me jump through hoops.

They handled it fairly and gave me updates along the way. It ended up being way easier than I thought it would be, and I’d definitely feel good buying from them again.
Seth-slonaker
March 26, 2026
"Really solid leather"
I picked up a pair of Frye boots recently, and the leather is probably what stood out to me the most. It feels thick and well-made, but after a few wears it started softening up nicely. They were a little stiff at first, which I kind of expected with real leather, but they don’t feel cheap at all. If you’re looking for boots that feel like they’ll hold up for a while, these are worth considering.
herbert1999
March 23, 2026
"Pretty easy to find my way around"
I kind of expected the site to be easy to use, and it pretty much confirmed that for me. I found what I was looking for quickly without having to click around too much
crystal1995
March 20, 2026
"I’ll admit, I expected the return..."
I’ll admit, I expected the return policy on the Frye site to be kind of a hassle to figure out, but it was surprisingly clear. The return window, item condition rules, and how to start the process were all easy to find without digging through a ton of fine print. I didn’t even have to contact support, which is always a plus. For buying shoes online, it made the whole thing feel a bit less risky.
CANADA
March 17, 2026
"I had to send back a pair..."
I had to send back a pair because they didn’t fit right, and I was kind of expecting the whole thing to be annoying, but it really wasn’t. The return label was easy to pull up, which was nice, and the refund showed up quickly too. i was just glad there wasn’t a bunch of back and forth or random confusing steps. The fit didn’t work out, but the return process was way smoother than I thought it would be.
JohnEast_63
March 15, 2026
"Got a quick reply"
Support got back to me fast, so that was nice. Kinda wish the reply felt a little warmer tho, but overall it did the job.
gerald.Comstock
March 01, 2026
"Boots arrived fine, but shipping took a while"
I ordered a pair of boots from Frye and they showed up in good condition, so no complaints there. I was just a little surprised by how long the shipping took. It wasn’t a huge delay or anything, but I had been expecting them to arrive a bit sooner. Overall, the boots were fine, the delivery was just okay.
enrique1989
February 28, 2026
"My Frye boots are still going strong"
I’ve had my Frye boots for about 3 years now, and they’re still holding up really well. My brother even commented the other day that the soles barely look worn, which is impressive considering how often I wear them.
WilliamJohnson
February 28, 2026
"Color looked just right"
I can't say it didn't match the photos, the color was pretty much exactly what I expected. Looked great in person.

View More Reviews

The Frye Company Q&A

What is the process for returns?

Are your frye judy boots made in china and is 6pm a approved retailer? i ordered boots from them and want to ensure they are authentic

Have a question about The Frye Company?
thefryecompany

The Frye Company Reviews

Coupons & Promo Codes

Customer Reviews

Questions & Answers

Ask a Question

Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.